02 July 2010

Crude oil in sand: how fast does it biodegrade?

At Tanah Merah, we have noticed signs of crude under the sand. Why should we be concerned about crude that seeps into the sand?
Oil spill signs on Tanah Merah weeks after 'clean up'
Even after crude is removed from sight, most of the spill remains in the ecosystem and much can penetrate our sandy beaches. The quality of our shore waters, for leisure beach goers to serious fish farms, depend on a balanced ecosystem. Of microscopic beings and seaweeds and all kinds of other creatures, each playing their role. An upset system can have devastating consequences as the mass fish deaths at Pasir Ris illustrates.

Here's what I learnt about what we know and don't know about how crude naturally biodegrades and some possible explanations of our recent sightings on our shores.

Crude oil that ends up on the shore have various forms: pancake oil (round, flat accumulations of heavy crude oil on the sand) or tar balls (weathered crude that form balls).
Broad expanse of Tanah Merah covered in
thin layer of crude,
5 Jun 10.
Pancake oil on Tanah Merah, 18 Jun 10

Less visible but still present in the water are oil sheen on the water surface, and oil droplets suspended in the water. Especially when dispersants are used to break up the crude into small droplets. These invisible oil bits seep into the sand. As the tides rise and fall, the water level changes, sucking the oil deeper into the sand.
Scum of crude floating on the tide line on Tanah Merah, 18 Jun 10

Oil that seeps into sand can only be removed by microbial degradation, i.e., when microbes 'eat' the oil.

Microbes 'eat' oil faster when there is oxygen. So oil in the water column and layer of sand near the water gets chomped faster. Deeper in the sand, where there is no oxygen, microbes can still 'eat' oil (in what is called anaerobic conditions) but they do so more slowly. Anaerobic degradation often results in black or grey icky muck. Is this the explanation for the grey muck I have seen at Tanah Merah?
With the outgoing tide, streams reveal grey mucky layers
under the sand at Tanah Merah,
1 Jul 10.

Microbes also 'eat' oil more slowly when it is cold. This is why crude is still found on the Exxon Valdez oil spill site many decades after, because the oil penetrated deeply into gravel sands and because it is cold there.

The oil itself may clog up the sand so that oxygen-rich water may not reach as deeply into the lower layers. This not only slows the speed at which oil-munching microbes degrade the buried crude, but also affects other animals that burrow into the sand and plants like seagrasses which put roots into the sand.
A crab burrowing into sand with
grey mucky under layer at Tanah Merah,
25 Jun 10.

Oil that remains in the sand can poison the surroundings for a long time. Crude oil contains substances so harmful that even small amounts can kill fish larvae.

A study in Florida hopes to find out for the Gulf oil spill: how much and to what depth oil washed onto the shore is carried into the sand; how rapidly microbes in the sand are breaking it down; and how the oil pollution may be impacting the structure and function of natural microbial communities that help to protect water quality on the coast.

How fast can microbes break down oil washed onto Gulf beaches?
EurekAlert 1 Jul 10;
Florida State examines oil degradation rates in beach sands, threats to beach ecosystems
A new Florida State University study is investigating how quickly the Deepwater Horizon oil carried into Gulf of Mexico beach sands is being degraded by the sands' natural microbial communities, and whether native oil-eating bacteria that wash ashore with the crude are helping or hindering that process.

What oceanography professors Markus Huettel and Joel E. Kostka learn will enable them to predict when most of the oil in the beaches will be gone. Their findings may also reveal ways to accelerate the oil degradation rate –– and speed matters, because toxic crude components that remain buried on Gulf Coast beaches may seep into the groundwater below.

"This enormous oil spill affects hundreds of miles of beaches in the Gulf of Mexico," Huettel said. "We can remove the oil from the beach surface, but oil is also carried deeper into the sand, and we need to understand what happens to that oil. Preventing groundwater contamination is crucial not only to Gulf Coast residents but also to coastal management and local economies like fisheries and tourism that depend on water quality."

"We will also study the effect of the dispersant known as Corexit on oil metabolism by natural microbial communities," Kostka said. "Through contacts in the field, my laboratory has acquired Corexit and source oil from the MC252 (Deepwater Horizon) well head for use in our experiments."

St. George Island, Fla., and Dauphin Island, Ala., have served as the primary research sites since early June, when the one-year study began. In addition, the researchers have obtained heavily oiled sand from Pensacola Beach, Fla., and from a barrier island off the Louisiana coast. If warranted by the oil's movement, they will also collect near-shore water and sediment samples from other Gulf beaches.

Funding for their collaborative research comes from a "RAPID" (Rapid Research Response) grant from the National Science Foundation.

Huettel and Kostka will analyze sediment cores collected from Gulf beaches to find out how much and to what depth oil washed onto the shore is carried into the sand; how rapidly microbes in the sand are breaking it down; and how the oil pollution may be impacting the structure and function of natural microbial communities that help to protect water quality on the coast.

"We'll also show how the oil itself alters the transport and filtration of oxygen-rich water into the beach by clogging the sand –– and how this clogging and resulting reduced oxygen availability in the sand affects the microbial community and degradation of buried oil," Huettel said.

Currents and winds carry the oil, and oil combined with dispersants –– chemicals that disperse the crude into very small oil droplets –– to the Gulf shores, where it washes up on sandy beaches.

Larger crude-oil accumulations such as pancake oil (round, flat accumulations of heavy crude oil) and tar balls (weathered crude oil accumulations that have been formed into ball-shaped structures) are deposited on the beach. Meanwhile, liquid oil (in the form of an oil sheen, or small dispersed droplets) can penetrate many feet deep into the permeable beach sand.

"Oil-filled water that washes up on the beach filters through the porous sediment and carries the oil with it into the sand," Huettel said. "In addition, the water-level drop between high and low tide causes a water-level drop within the beach sediment that can transport oil that has penetrated into the beach into even deeper sediment layers."

"Crude oil is a natural component that constantly seeps out of Gulf of Mexico sediments ––obviously in much smaller quantities than those now caused by the drilling accident –– so native microbes have evolved that consume this oil and thereby degrade it," Kostka said. "These microorganisms include bacteria and also some microalgae that live in the water column and the sediments of the Gulf of Mexico."

Kostka said oil accumulations deposited on the beach surface are easily removed by, for example, scraping off the top layer of sand. However, the oil components that penetrate into the sand can only be removed by microbial degradation.

"If oxygen is present –– as it is in the water and in the upper layers of the beach sand –– the microbes decompose the oil aerobically (by using oxygen)," Kostka said. "This degradation process is much faster than the degradation under anaerobic conditions (when no oxygen is available), such as those found in deeper sediment layers of the beach. That's why at the site of the Exxon Valdez oil spill in Alaska, oil can still be found deeply buried in the gravel beach sediments, because anaerobic microbial degradation is slow and, in Alaska, slower still because of the cold climate."

"Unfortunately, said Huettel, "crude oil contains such harmful substances that even small amounts can kill fish larvae –– which means that oil stored in deep layers of beach sediment present a potential source of toxins to near-shore waters and groundwater."


Related Posts with Thumbnails